Artistic legacy: how to manage the future of a collection
Receiving a legacy of works of art can be an extraordinary cultural opportunity, but also a multidisciplinary challenge that brings together legal, tax, ethical and conservation considerations. Far from being a mere act of asset transfer, managing an artistic legacy involves preserving the donor’s memory, safeguarding the integrity of the pieces and deciding on their future within a framework that respects both the testator’s wishes and the public interest.
Approaching a legacy with rigour requires method, professional support and careful planning, enabling the collection to become a genuine cultural asset.
Inventory and cataloguing: the essential starting point
Before making any decisions about the final destination of the works, the first step is to draw up a comprehensive inventory. This inventory should include full cataloguing details: authorship, date, technique, dimensions, condition, provenance, certificates of authenticity and any other relevant documentation. And, of course,an up-to-date market valuation.
It is equally important to preserve the donor’s archive and personal records, as this information helps place each piece within its historical and even emotional context. Accurate cataloguing prevents mistakes or hasty decisions and is indispensable for legal formalities, insurance, valuations and any future donations or sales.
It is always advisable to engage a specialist who can carry out this cataloguing and assess the physical condition of the works, particularly in legacies that include pieces requiring restoration.
Review of the legal and testamentary framework
Legal analysis of the legacy is essential. Some testators include specific instructions, such as:
- an obligation to keep the works together
- conservation requirements
- limits on sale
- requirements for public display
- prohibition on fragmenting the collection
In other cases, the heir has full freedom, which can be even more complex due to the number of decisions involved. Reviewing these matters with a lawyer specialising in art law ensures that any actions respect the donor’s wishes and comply with current legislation.
What should be done with the legacy? Options depending on each case
Once the inventory has been completed and the legal framework reviewed, the most complex decision arises: defining the future of the legacy. There are several alternatives, each with different advantages depending on the value of the collection, the testator’s wishes and the heir’s circumstances.
a) Donation to museums, foundations or cultural institutions
This guarantees professional conservation, visibility and long-term stability.
However, many museums apply strict criteria before accepting works, and some no longer accept donations due to lack of space. This option offers tax benefits, but involves relinquishing ownership in order to transform the legacy into a cultural asset of public interest.
b) Temporary loans to institutions
This allows the works to be exhibited and properly conserved without losing ownership.
Loans are governed by specific contracts covering insurance, specialised transport and controlled environmental conditions.
c) Creation of a foundation or artist’s archive
Ideal where the legacy relates to a single creator or includes significant documentation.
It enables the preservation, study and dissemination of the work.
Its main drawback is the loss of individual ownership, as the pieces become the property of the foundation.
d) Partial or selective sale
In some cases, selling part of the legacy can help finance the conservation of the remainder, support cultural projects or meet tax obligations.
This should always be undertaken with professional advice to avoid loss of value or decisions that undermine the integrity of the collection.
Preventive conservation and insurance: the great overlooked aspects
Art is extremely sensitive to environmental conditions. A poorly stored legacy can deteriorate rapidly.
It is essential to ensure:
- stable temperature
- controlled humidity
- appropriate lighting
- suitable packaging
It is also crucial to take out a specific insurance policy, both for domestic storage and for transport or exhibitions. These measures involve costs that the heir must anticipate and plan for.
Taxation of an artistic legacy
Art legacies may give rise to inheritance tax liabilities, although there are allowances and exemptions depending on the autonomous community and the type of work. Cultural donations, in turn, may offer significant tax deductions.
Specialist tax advice is key to optimising these decisions without compromising the integrity of the collection.
Conclusion
Managing an artistic legacy is not a mere formality: it is an act of cultural responsibility. Inheriting art means inheriting a part of history, creativity and the donor’s memory. The final decision must balance this emotional legacy with the heir’s practical realities and the aim that the works continue to be appreciated.
Ultimately, transforming a legacy into a viable cultural project is a way of honouring the donor and ensuring that the works continue to enrich cultural life beyond a single generation.
Do you need advice? Access our practice areas related to the management of artistic legacies:
