The Judgment 367/2026 of 30 June 2026 of Spain’s National Court (Audiencia Nacional) (ECLI: ES:AN:2026:2870) has annulled the guidance on the use of biometric systems for attendance monitoring, published by the Spanish Data Protection Authority (AEPD) in November 2023.

The ruling is particularly significant because the guidance had introduced stricter criteria for the use of biometric technologies, including fingerprint recognition, facial recognition and other biometric systems, for attendance monitoring and access control.

Many businesses using these technologies ultimately replaced them because of the difficulties involved in meeting the AEPD’s requirements and the regulatory risks associated with continuing to use such systems.

However, although the judgment annuls the guidance, it is important to emphasise that it does not establish that the use of biometric systems is lawful, nor does it find that the AEPD’s underlying criteria were incorrect. Rather, the annulment is based on a procedural defect.

Why has the AEPD’s guidance on biometrics been annulled?

The judgment follows a legal challenge brought by the Spanish Association of Security Companies (Asociación Española de Empresas de Seguridad), representing a sector particularly affected by the criteria set out in the guidance concerning the use of biometric identification systems.

The issue considered by the National Court was whether the AEPD could use a guidance document to establish criteria which, in practice, directly influenced the decisions of businesses and data controllers.

The issue considered by the National Court was whether the AEPD could use a guidance document to establish criteria which, in practice, directly influenced the decisions of businesses and data controllers. The AEPD argued that the document was merely advisory. However, the National Court took a different view. The guidance itself stated that its purpose was to determine the criteria applicable to attendance monitoring through biometric systems. Furthermore, the Authority subsequently relied on those same criteria in its decisions.

The Court found that the document established:

The Court found that the document established: “A restrictive framework for the implementation of biometric data processing systems for attendance monitoring, which clearly seeks to influence data controllers’ decisions regarding the data processing methods they use and discourages distributors of these systems in our country.

The National Court based its reasoning on a fundamental legal principle:

The National Court based its reasoning on a fundamental legal principle: “The need to consider things for what they are, rather than what they are called.”

Accordingly, describing the document as “guidance” was not sufficient if, in terms of its content and effects, it effectively operated as an instrument establishing general criteria applicable to third parties.

For such circumstances, Spanish legislation provides for an AEPD Circular, which is subject to a specific procedure for its adoption and publication. As that procedure had not been followed, the National Court concluded that the guidance was, in substance, a Circular and ordered its annulment.

What are the implications of the ruling for the use of biometrics?

In my point of view, it is important not to interpret the judgment too broadly.

Although the guidance has been annulled, this does not mean that all the substantive criteria it contained have ceased to apply.

The National Court did not assess whether the requirements relating to the necessity, proportionality, data minimisation or risk assessment of the processing were correct. Nor did it question the enhanced protection afforded to biometric data under the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). What the Court criticised was the procedure used by the AEPD to establish criteria with general application.

For this reason, I believe a cautious approach remains necessary. The AEPD could still determine that a particular biometric system breaches data protection legislation if it bases its decision directly on the GDPR, Spain’s Organic Law on Personal Data Protection and Guarantee of Digital Rights (LOPDGDD), relevant case law and the specific circumstances of the processing, without needing to rely on the annulled guidance.

Biometrics and attendance monitoring: can employees clock in using fingerprints or facial recognition?

The judgment does not support such a conclusion. The annulment of the guidance does not remove the requirements arising directly from data protection legislation.

Biometric data processed for the purpose of uniquely identifying an individual remain subject to the enhanced protection requirements established under the GDPR.

I therefore consider that the annulment of the guidance should not be interpreted as authorisation to introduce fingerprint recognition, facial recognition or other biometric attendance monitoring systems.

The lawfulness of such processing will continue to depend on the specific circumstances of each case and, in particular, on the existence of an appropriate legal basis for processing this type of data, together with compliance with the other obligations and principles established by data protection legislation.

Among other matters, businesses must be able to demonstrate:

  • the purpose of the processing;

  • why the use of biometrics is necessary;

  • which alternatives have been consider

  • why those alternatives are unsuitable; and

  • why the processing is considered proportionate.

Consequently, any decision to introduce these systems requires a thorough prior assessment of the circumstances of each case to establish whether their use is sufficiently justified. Such a decision should not be taken solely because the guidance has been annulled.

Conclusion: the use of biometrics following the annulment of the AEPD’s guidance

The annulment of the AEPD’s guidance represents a significant development, but it does not, in itself, change the legal framework governing the processing of biometric data.

The National Court has neither declared these systems lawful nor generally invalidated the substantive criteria applied by the Authority. Instead, it found that criteria with clear effects on third parties had been established through a guidance document without following the legally prescribed procedure.

The judgment should therefore not be regarded as giving businesses the green light to use biometric systems. The AEPD may continue to apply the GDPR and the LOPDGDD directly and reach conclusions similar to those it has adopted previously.

It will also be important to monitor the AEPD’s response, both to establish whether it has lodged an appeal against the judgment and to determine whether it intends to reintroduce criteria in this area through the appropriate legal instrument, such as the adoption and publication of a Circular.

In an area where the circumstances of each case may differ, obtaining sound data protection legal advice is particularly important before making decisions.

At Devesa Law, we can help businesses review their procedures and systems to ensure compliance with data protection legislation.

FAQs on biometrics and the annulment of the AEPD’s guidance

What has Spain’s National Court decided regarding the AEPD’s guidance on biometrics?

The National Court has annulled the guidance on the use of biometric systems for attendance monitoring published by the AEPD in November 2023. The annulment is based on a procedural defect concerning the legal instrument used by the Authority, rather than a finding that the substantive criteria contained in the guidance were incorrect.

Does the annulment mean businesses can once again use biometrics for employee clocking-in systems?

No. The judgment does not provide blanket authorisation for the use of biometric technologies, including fingerprint recognition, facial recognition or other biometric identification systems. Businesses must continue to comply with the requirements established under data protection legislation.

Why has the National Court annulled the guidance on biometrics?

The National Court found that the guidance did not merely provide recommendations but established general criteria capable of influencing the decisions of businesses and data controllers. Given its practical effects, the Court considered that it was, in substance, an AEPD Circular, although the required procedure for adopting such an instrument had not been followed.

Do biometric data remain subject to enhanced legal protection?

Yes. Biometric data used to uniquely identify an individual remain subject to the enhanced protection requirements established under the GDPR. The annulment of the guidance does not, in itself, alter the legal framework governing this category of data.

Can businesses use fingerprint or facial recognition systems to monitor employee attendance?

This depends on the specific circumstances of each case. Businesses must have an appropriate legal basis and be able to justify, among other matters, the purpose of the processing, the necessity of using biometric technologies, the alternatives considered and the proportionality of the measure.

What should businesses consider before implementing a biometric system?

Before introducing a biometric system, businesses should undertake a thorough assessment to establish why the use of biometrics is necessary, which less intrusive alternatives are available, why those alternatives are unsuitable and whether the processing is proportionate to its intended purpose.

Can the AEPD still impose penalties for unlawful biometric data processing following this judgment?

The annulment of the guidance does not prevent the AEPD from assessing the lawfulness of biometric data processing by directly applying the GDPR, the LOPDGDD, relevant case law and the specific circumstances of each case. The judgment therefore does not eliminate the regulatory risks associated with using biometric technologies in breach of data protection legislation.

Can the AEPD introduce general criteria on biometrics again?

Yes. The judgment challenges the procedure used to establish criteria with general application, but it does not prevent the AEPD from introducing such criteria again through the appropriate legal instrument, such as a Circular adopted and published in accordance with the applicable procedure.

What does the annulment of the guidance actually mean for businesses?

The main change is that the 2023 guidance has been annulled as a legal instrument. However, businesses should not interpret the judgment as giving them unrestricted permission to implement biometric systems, since the obligations and principles arising from data protection legislation remain applicable.

Do you need legal advice? Find out more about our relevant practice area:

Data Protection

Rate this post

Related Articles

Contacta / Contact us