What tax consolidation is and the advantages it offers family holding companies and business groups
As a company grows, it commonly begins to expand its activity and diversify its business lines by incorporating or acquiring new companies. This growth usually involves the creation of holding-type corporate structures, in which a parent company holds interests in various operating companies.
This corporate structure allows the different areas of a business to be organised more efficiently. However, it also raises new needs from a tax perspective, as there comes a point at which being taxed individually, company by company, no longer makes economic sense. It is at this point that the tax consolidation regime becomes particularly relevant.
The tax consolidation regime is governed by Chapter VI of Title VII of Law 27/2014, of 27 November, on Corporate Income Tax (LIS), Articles 55 to 75, and has become a strategic tool that every family business or business group should consider.
Its main distinguishing feature is that the group of companies determines its Corporate Income Tax base jointly and files a single tax return, rather than being taxed solely on the individual results of each of the companies that make up the business group.
This regime is particularly attractive for business groups that include companies with differing levels of profitability, or in which transactions between group companies take place on a recurring basis, as it offers significant advantages from both a tax and a financial standpoint.
What is tax consolidation?
Tax consolidation is a special, optional regime that allows a set of companies forming part of a group, as defined in Article 58 of the LIS, to be taxed jointly for Corporate Income Tax purposes as though they were a single taxpayer, by filing a single return (Form 220), instead of each company settling the tax individually.
In this regard, the tax group comprises a parent company and one or more subsidiaries, provided that the requirements set out in the LIS are met. For these purposes, the Corporate Income Tax Law provides that the taxpayer under the tax consolidation regime is the tax group, with the parent company being responsible for settling the aggregated results of all the subsidiaries that make up the group.
Among other particularities, applying this regime means that the group’s tax base is determined starting from the individual tax bases of its member entities, subsequently applying the eliminations and incorporations provided for under tax legislation.
It is important to note that tax consolidation should not be confused with accounting consolidation, since accounting consolidation may be mandatory depending on the size of the group. Tax consolidation, by contrast, as mentioned above, is always optional, and its application will always be a matter of tax planning.
Which companies can form a tax group?
Article 58 of the LIS sets out the requirements that must be met for a tax group to exist, specifically the following:
- There must be a parent company holding, directly or indirectly, at least 75% of the share capital of the subsidiaries (or 70% in the case of listed companies), and maintaining that interest throughout the entire tax period.
- The parent company must hold the majority of the voting rights in the subsidiaries.
- None of the group companies may fall within any of the grounds for exclusion set out in Article 58.4 of the LIS (for example, being subject to a different tax rate, being in insolvency proceedings or being exempt from the tax).
How do you opt into the tax consolidation regime?
Once the above requirements have been met, all the group companies must agree to apply the tax consolidation regime by resolution of the Board of Directors (or equivalent body) and notify the Spanish Tax Agency before the start of the tax period in which it is to apply.
Once the option has been exercised, the regime remains in force indefinitely for as long as the requirements continue to be met, unless it is expressly waived.
What are the main advantages of tax consolidation?
A. Offsetting tax bases between group companies
One of the main advantages of this regime is the ability to offset the results of the companies that make up the tax group jointly.
Thus, where in the same financial year one group company obtains a positive tax base and another generates a negative tax base, the latter can have an immediate effect on the determination of the group’s tax base, since profits are automatically offset against losses, thereby reducing the tax cost borne by the group, in accordance with the specific rules and limitations established by the regime itself.
Consequently, this produces an immediate improvement for the group in terms of finances and liquidity: if one group company makes losses and another makes profits in the same financial year, both amounts are automatically offset when determining the group’s tax base (Art. 62 LIS), with no need to wait for future years to use the negative tax base generated. This can mean an immediate financial saving compared with individual taxation, under which each company must generate its own profits in order to offset its own losses.
This regime is particularly attractive for groups whose companies are at different stages of development; for example, established and highly profitable companies alongside others that are undergoing investment, expansion or the launch of new business lines and are incurring losses.
B. Deferral of taxation on intra-group transactions
Another advantage offered by this regime is the treatment of transactions carried out between the companies that make up the tax consolidation group.
Specifically, transactions between group companies, such as sales of inventory or fixed assets, provision of services, etc., give rise to eliminations (Art. 64 LIS) that defer the tax result until it is realised vis-à-vis third parties outside the group, through the corresponding incorporations (Art. 65 LIS). In practice, this allows assets to be reorganised within the group without triggering an immediate tax cost.
This feature is especially important for groups that regularly carry out internal reorganisations, asset transfers, provision of services or financing between their various companies.
C. Joint application of deductions and limits
Certain limits and incentives, such as the limits on the deductibility of finance costs, the capitalisation reserve or the levelling reserve, are calculated and applied at group level. This can optimise the use of deductions that an individual group company would be unable to absorb on its own due to insufficient tax liability.
D. Greater efficiency in the group’s financial and tax planning.
The tax consolidation regime makes it possible to approach tax and financial planning from a global perspective, taking into account the economic reality of the business group as a whole.
In this regard, settling Corporate Income Tax on an aggregated basis provides a unified view of the group’s economic, financial and tax position, making it easier to plan tax-related cash flows and improving the flow of information to the tax authorities, while avoiding a lack of coordination between companies that, although legally independent, form part of the same business project.
A decision best assessed on a case-by-case basis
Tax consolidation is not an automatic formula for tax savings, as it requires a prior analysis of the group’s perimeter, the individual tax position of each company (prior tax credits, negative tax bases generated before joining the group, pending deductions, etc.) and the future implications, given that the regime binds the group indefinitely unless waived. A sound design of the consolidation perimeter is therefore essential.
Accordingly, before opting for this regime, we always recommend a bespoke study assessing both the potential savings and the medium-term effects on the group’s structure.
Could your business group benefit from tax consolidation?
At Devesa, we analyse the corporate and tax structure of each group to determine whether applying the tax consolidation regime may be advisable, identify its main opportunities and risks, and support our clients throughout the analysis process as well as with its implementation and compliance before the tax authorities.
What is tax consolidation?
It is a special, optional regime, governed by Articles 55 to 75 of Law 27/2014 (LIS), that allows a group of companies to be taxed jointly for Corporate Income Tax purposes as though they were a single taxpayer, by filing a single return (Form 220).
What requirements must a group of companies meet to apply this regime?
There must be a parent company holding, directly or indirectly, at least 75% of the share capital of the subsidiaries (70% if they are listed) and holding the majority of the voting rights. In addition, none of the group companies may fall within any of the grounds for exclusion set out in Article 58.4 of the LIS.
Is tax consolidation mandatory if the requirements are met?
No. Tax consolidation is always optional, unlike accounting consolidation, which may be mandatory depending on the size of the group. Its application is a matter of the company’s tax planning.
What are the main advantages of this regime?
Among others, it allows positive and negative tax bases to be offset immediately between group companies, defers taxation on intra-group transactions, enables certain deductions and limits (such as the capitalisation or levelling reserve) to be applied jointly, and allows the group’s overall taxation to be planned more efficiently.
Once tax consolidation has been elected, can it be discontinued?
Yes, but the regime remains in force indefinitely while the requirements are met, unless it is expressly waived. That is why it is essential to analyse the group’s perimeter and the future implications carefully before opting for this regime.
Need advice? Explore our practice areas related to the advantages that tax consolidation offers family holding companies and business groups: