General meetings during the holiday period
Unlike the courts, corporate activity does not come to a standstill in August, and general meetings may still be convened. Partners are not exempt from the obligations, rights and deadlines associated with the operation of a company while they are on holiday.
It is relatively common for general meetings to be convened during the summer months, precisely when many partners are away from their usual place of residence on holiday.
Sometimes, these are particularly significant general meetings, at which approval is strategically sought for major transactions, amendments to the articles of association, appointments or removals of directors or senior executives, related-party transactions, financing arrangements or dividend distributions. This may occur in the knowledge that a shareholder who might vote against a particular proposal could be unable to attend the general meeting in person when the matter is discussed.
The problem therefore arises when partners are on holiday and cannot attend in person, or doing so would entail considerable difficulty or expense, even if they have received due notice of the meeting.
Sometimes, these are particularly significant general meetings, at which approval is strategically sought for major transactions, amendments to the articles of association, appointments or removals of directors or senior executives, related-party transactions, financing arrangements or dividend distributions. This may occur in the knowledge that a shareholder who might vote against a particular proposal could be unable to attend the general meeting in person when the matter is discussed.
The problem therefore arises when shareholders are on holiday and cannot attend in person, or doing so would entail considerable difficulty or expense, even if they have received due notice of the meeting.
In such circumstances, several alternatives are available: attending remotely, appointing a duly authorised representative, or, where applicable, using mechanisms that allow resolutions to be validly passed without physical attendance.
However, none of these options should be taken for granted, primarily because their validity will largely depend on the provisions of the company’s articles of association. In other words, advance planning is essential for partners on holiday.
If these circumstances have not been expressly addressed in the articles of association beforehand, the shareholder concerned may have no choice but to interrupt their holiday and attend the meeting in person, or forgo exercising their rights to information and to vote on the matters concerned.
Can partners avoid attending general meetings in person while on holiday?
The legal answer is: it depends. It depends on the provisions of the company’s articles of association and how the shareholder’s absence is addressed.
The Spanish Companies Act (Ley de Sociedades de Capital, “LSC”) provides for various mechanisms for shareholder participation. Articles 179 et seq. regulate the right to attend general meetings, representation and voting rights. Accordingly, when general meetings coincide with a holiday period, there are generally three options worth considering:
Attendance in person, where possible.
Attendance through a representative, subject to a careful review of the applicable legislation and the articles of association to ensure full compliance with the relevant requirements.
Remote attendance, where permitted by the articles of association and the conditions set out in the notice convening the meeting.
Therefore, regardless of the option being considered, the first step should always be the same: reviewing the company’s articles of association. In corporate law, the articles of association are far more than a mere formality. Among other matters, they are the primary reference for determining how general meetings are convened and conducted, who may represent a shareholder, the requirements applicable to such representation, and whether remote attendance or fully virtual general meetings are permitted.
As regards remote attendance, Article 182 LSC allows partners to attend general meetings by electronic devices, provided that the articles of association expressly authorise this possibility and the identity of the participant is duly verified.
Furthermore, the notice convening the meeting must specify the deadlines, procedures and arrangements for exercising the rights of shareholders participating remotely, with a view to ensuring that the meeting is conducted properly.
Can shareholders on holiday appoint someone else to represent them at general meetings?
Representation can be a particularly useful solution for shareholders on holiday, especially where the notice convening the meeting or the articles of association do not allow the alternatives discussed above.
However, this raises one of the most common mistakes in corporate practice: not everyone is legally entitled to represent a shareholder at a general meeting.
Article 183 LSC provides that, in a Spanish private limited liability company (sociedad de responsabilidad limitada, S.L.), a shareholder may only be represented at a general meeting by one of the following persons:
- Their spouse.
- An ascendant or descendant.
- Another partner.
- A person holding a general power of attorney granted by public instrument, conferring authority to manage all the assets held by the shareholder being represented within Spain.
The provision also states that the articles of association may authorise representation by other persons. This final point is fundamental. However, it is relatively common to find articles of association that simply refer to the statutory regime established by the LSC when regulating shareholder representation.
Where this is the case, the possibility of appointing a third party as a representative may be considerably restricted. This is particularly relevant for partners on holiday who cannot attend the meeting in person.
Consider a relatively common situation. A shareholder receives notice of a general meeting while on holiday. Unable to attend, they decide to authorise their lawyer to attend the meeting on their behalf and vote on the proposed resolutions.
At first glance, this appears to be a perfectly reasonable solution.
However, in an S.L. whose articles of association refer to the statutory regime under Article 183 LSC, a specific authorisation or a power of attorney granted solely for the purpose of attending that particular meeting may not be sufficient.
In such circumstances, if the lawyer is not the shareholder’s spouse, ascendant, descendant or a fellow shareholder, they must qualify as a person holding the corresponding general power of attorney, granted by public instrument, with authority to manage all the shareholder’s assets located in Spain. Only then would the statutory requirement be satisfied.
Consequently, a power of attorney limited to representing the grantor at the company’s general meeting may fail to meet the requirements of Article 183 LSC where the articles of association have not extended the categories of persons eligible to act as representatives.
This may have a significant practical consequence: the representative may attend the meeting but nevertheless lack the necessary legal authority to exercise the rights of the shareholder they purport to represent. The regime applicable to Spanish public limited companies (sociedades anónimas, S.A.) is more permissive. Article 184 LSC provides that any partner entitled to attend a general meeting may appoint another person to represent them, even if that person is not a shareholder, although the articles of association may restrict this right.
Such representation must be conferred in writing or by means of remote communication that comply with the applicable statutory requirements, and a specific authorisation must be granted for each meeting.
Therefore, distinguishing between an S.L. and an S.A. is essential. A seemingly straightforward review of the company’s legal form may completely change the assessment of who can validly represent a shareholder at a general meeting.
In our experience, these difficulties are far from theoretical. On several occasions, we have had to examine powers of attorney submitted by other lawyers seeking to represent shareholders at general meetings of private limited liability companies, only to find that those powers did not satisfy the requirements established by the articles of association and the statutory regime under Article 183 LSC.
The outcome can be particularly problematic: the representative attends the general meeting, but their authority is challenged and they are ultimately prevented from exercising the shareholder’s rights to attend and vote on their behalf.
Planning ahead: key considerations for shareholders on holiday
Being on holiday should not prevent partners from exercising their corporate rights. However, nor should it lead them to assume that any method of attendance or representation will necessarily be valid. Although the LSC provides several alternatives, including physical attendance, representation, remote attendance and, where applicable, fully virtual general meetings, the most appropriate approach is to plan ahead and establish a suitable strategy. The availability of these mechanisms is subject to the applicable legal framework and, in particular, the provisions of the company’s articles of association.
In such circumstances, obtaining corporate legal advice in advance enables partners on holiday not only to identify the most appropriate means of participation, but also to anticipate potential challenges to a representative’s authority and ensure that the participation of the shareholder or board member produces its full legal effects.
FAQ about general meetings during holidays
Can shareholders on holiday choose not to attend general meetings in person?
It depends on the provisions of the company’s articles of association. The LSC provides alternatives for shareholders on holiday, including representation, remote attendance and fully virtual general meetings. However, the validity of these arrangements depends on the relevant provisions of the articles of association.
Who can represent shareholders at general meetings of an S.L.?
Under Article 183 LSC, a shareholder may be represented by their spouse, an ascendant or descendant, another shareholder, or a person holding a general power of attorney granted by public instrument authorising them to manage all the shareholder’s assets in Spain, unless the articles of association extend the categories of eligible representatives.
Are the rules governing shareholder representation at general meetings the same for an S.L. and an S.A.?
No. The regime applicable to public limited companies (S.A.) is more flexible. Article 184 LSC allows a shareholder to be represented by another person, even if that person is not a shareholder, unless the articles of association restrict this right.
Can partners attend general meetings by video conference?
Yes, provided that the articles of association expressly permit remote attendance and the shareholder’s identity is duly verified, in accordance with Article 182 LSC. Since 2021, Article 182 bis LSC has also permitted fully virtual general meetings.
What risks do partners on holiday face if their representative does not meet the requirements of Article 183 LSC?
The representative’s authority may be challenged at the general meeting, potentially preventing them from exercising the shareholder’s voting rights, even if they are physically present.
It is therefore advisable to verify the validity of the power of attorney before the meeting takes place.
Do you need legal advice? Visit our practice area for assistance with general meetings held during holiday periods: